The Official Magazine of the Bluewater Cruising Association
 Share   Print  

Cruising Makes You Stupid: Sleep Science, Part 1

Rob Murray

Avant
Beneteau First 435 Sloop
November 15th, 2026

*Editor’s note: in Part 1 (of 2), the author provides a comprehensive look at what the science of sleep — from Navy destroyers to long-haul trucks — says about who’s awake (and how smart they are) on your boat.  In Part 2, recommendations for cruisers will be offered regarding sleep practices.

Before we set off in Avant in 2013, I researched watch systems for a shorthanded crew: what works, and how can two people cover 24 hours without becoming exhausted. Then we set out, and one night on an overnight coastal passage at oh-dark-thirty I find the wind has built to the top of the forecast range, the autopilot has moved from muttering to stuttering to itself, and a radar contact eleven miles out is doing something ambiguous at fourteen knots. I have just woken myself up with my chin hitting my chest (for the third time this watch) which means I have no idea how long I was out, which means I have no idea how long that contact has been doing whatever it is doing. Every offshore sailor knows this hour. It is the hour when the plotter starts looking like modern art, when you read the same AIS target three times and still don’t “get it,” when you catch yourself bargaining with the kettle. Sleep scientists have a name for it (the circadian nadir) and they have measured, with lab-grade precision, exactly how useless a human being is when in its grip.

On our overnight and multi-day passages I conducted a simple citizen-science experiment: I solved a Sudoku puzzle at the same time every day on a tablet before, during, and after passages and recorded the scores. They dropped 15–20% on the first night of a passage and did not fully recover until five days post-passage. Since I operate at reduced intellectual capacity even when fully rested (just ask Debra), this seemed worth taking seriously. As we prepare for longer passages, I’ve revisited the science.

What the US Navy Learned

In 2017 the destroyers USS Fitzgerald and USS John S. McCain were involved in collisions that killed seventeen sailors. The Navy’s Comprehensive Review found fatigue “embedded” in both: exhausted watch teams, no protected sleep, schedules that treated rest as something that happened if there was time. The response was not a safety poster but a multi-year research program with wrist actigraphs, four different watch schedules tested at sea, reaction times measured like GPS positions. Researchers Shattuck and Matsangas at the Naval Postgraduate School spent the better part of a decade on the question every cruising sailor asks: what is the least-bad way to divide 24 hours on a moving platform? Their answer is not what most of us do, and shift workers, solo racers, truckers, and Max Ebb all reached roughly the same place by different routes.

The Navy is not the only one to have paid for this lesson. Shortly after 0100 on October 13, 2016, the articulated tug-barge Nathan E. Stewart ran aground on Edge Reef near Bella Bella, British Columbia and sank, spilling roughly 110,000 litres of diesel into Heiltsuk First Nation waters. The second mate, alone on the bridge (contrary to Canadian regulations), had fallen asleep and missed a planned course change. The report noted the tug “was not equipped with a Bridge Navigational Watch Alarm System (BNWAS)”. A BNWAS sounds an alarm if the watch officer on the bridge of a ship falls asleep, becomes otherwise incapacitated, or is absent for too long a time. Automated on larger ships, the kitchen timer in your pocket is the cruisers’ equivalent. For 58 of the 72 hours before the grounding, the crew had been on 6-on/6-off; the second mate never slept more than six and a half hours in a day, sometimes as little as four and a half hours. The Transportation Safety Board’s report (M16P0378, 2018) carries a sentence that should be laminated: 6-on/6-off, the Board wrote, “was not designed according to principles of modern sleep science.” That schedule was not some exotic commercial aberration, and many cruising sailors choose it voluntarily. A professional mariner fell asleep on it, missed a turn, and put a tug on the rocks at 0100: squarely in the circadian low, exactly when the science said it would happen.

Your Brain on No Sleep

In 1997, Australian researchers Dawson and Reid published this in Nature: after about seventeen hours of sustained wakefulness, psychomotor performance impairment was comparable to that associated with a blood-alcohol level of 0.05 percent. After twenty-four hours, about 0.10 percent. The legal driving limit in most of North America sits between 0.05 and 0.08. A normal cruising day that rolls into a night watch (up at 0700-ish, on deck at midnight) puts you at the helm performing like a legally drunk driver. The difference is that the drunk driver at least chose the impairment deliberately.

Worse, the impairment is cumulative and invisible. In 2003, Hans Van Dongen’s team restricted volunteers to four or six hours of sleep a night for two weeks; cognitive performance cratered to the level of one to two full nights with no sleep, and the subjects barely noticed. Sleepiness ratings hardly moved while reaction times fell off a cliff: your brain is the last instrument on the boat you should trust to self-calibrate.

And you cannot fix it with a lie-in: in 2003, Gregory Belenky’s team showed that after a week of restricted sleep, three full nights of eight-hour recovery did not fully restore performance. The debt compounds daily, and one good night does not clear it. Budget up to a week of being slightly stupid after a passage, not a weekend.

The shift-work researchers add the timing. Folkard and Tucker’s 2003 review found accident risk climbing six percent on the second consecutive night shift, seventeen on the third, thirty-six on the fourth — roughly doubling by the twelfth hour on duty. The danger peak sits at 0300 to 0500, which is why Britain’s marine accident investigators found fatigue involved in a third of 66 serious accidents they studied, most of them between midnight and 0600 with a lone watchkeeper on 6-on/6-off.

If you think falling asleep on watch doesn’t happen: 73 percent of mariners admitted to it in a World Maritime University survey, and sleep efficiency at sea runs 75–79 percent against 85–90 ashore. An hour in the bunk is not an hour of sleep. It never was.

None of this denigrates your character. It describes your plumbing, and it is not just cognition. A 2025 meta-analysis (Kong and colleagues) found sleep deprivation impairs endurance, coordination, balance, and fine motor control while making everything feel harder. A tired sailor can still pull a rope; what goes missing is the ability to balance on a heaving foredeck and the judgment to clip on. If you have ever dropped a winch handle on your foot at 0400, you have conducted the experiment yourself.

How Sleep Actually Works: the Ninety-Minute Version

Sleep is not one thing. It runs in roughly ninety-minute cycles, four to six in a normal night, alternating between light sleep, deep slow-wave sleep, and REM — the dreaming stage, when the brain is nearly as active as when awake.

Two drives govern sleep. The first is sleep pressure: the longer you are awake, the more adenosine accumulates in the brain, demanding sleep, a debt that fragmented naps only partly clear, so it compounds daily. The second is the circadian clock, which drives alertness to its minimum between about 0200 and 0600. At 0300 on your third night offshore, the two stack. That is why the watch feels the way it does, and no amount of “character” changes it.

Deep sleep is front-loaded: most of it happens in the first half of the night, and the sleep-deprived brain dives straight for it (which is why every nap starts with the good stuff).

There are two practical consequences to this. First, sleep inertia: waking from deep sleep leaves you groggy and impaired for twenty to thirty minutes, sometimes longer. A twenty-minute nap mostly stays in light sleep and wakes clean; a fifty-minute nap can drop you into the deep end and surface you to take the deck feeling like you have been hit with a shovel. One caveat, from a 2017 review (Hilditch, Dorrian and Banks): the evidence for a universal “under thirty minutes is safe” rule is weaker than the folklore suggests. So after any nap, give yourself a margin (wake, check the horizon, check the instruments, let the brain sync with reality) before doing anything critical. Never wake from a nap and charge straight forward in 35 knots just because the alarm says it is your turn.

Second, anchor sleep. In 1983, Minors and Waterhouse showed that about four hours of sleep taken at the same time every day keeps the body’s circadian rhythms locked to the twenty-four-hour day even when the rest of your sleep is scattered. A minimum of four fixed hours may be the most useful habit a short-handed crew can protect.

If there is one idea to carry away from the science, it is not “sleep more.” It is “sleep regularly.”

What the Canadian Navy Found Out

In 2015, Shattuck and Matsangas compared four real watchbills at sea. Fixed 3-on/9-off — same watches, same times, every day beat 6-on/6-off on every measure: more sleep (6.46 vs 5.89 hours), less sleepiness, steadier reactions.

Then the paradox. The rotating 5-on/10-off (sometimes called the “five and dimes”) produced the most total sleep of all, nearly seven hours a day, and the worst cognitive performance. The sleep fell at biologically wrong times, and there was no fixed daily anchor sleep. Most sleep, worst brain. Fleet-wide: underway sailors averaged 6.6 hours a day, four out of five were poor sleepers, and the worst-sleeping group reacted twenty-one percent slower.

Canada ran its own trials. A Royal Canadian Navy study evaluated six watch systems over four at-sea trials and published the results in 2022 in Military Medicine. The winner, for fatigue and quality of life, was a straight 1-in-3 eight-hour rotation — one eight-hour watch a day, same times daily. The best two-section system was 8-4-4-8. Both shared the Window of Circadian Low — the melatonin peak between about 0200 and 0600 — instead of hanging it around one watchkeeper’s neck.

A newer experiment speaks directly to the two-person cruising problem. A 2025 German Navy field trial — 48 sailors, two vessels — compared 6-on/6-off with 7-5-5-7, designed to park sleep inside the biological night. The 7-5-5-7 produced fourteen more minutes of nighttime sleep at ten percent greater efficiency; the old 6/6 schedule produced more daytime sleep instead — the poor-quality kind. This provided a clean demonstration that when you sleep can matter as much as how long.

After the USS Fitzgerald and USS McCain incidents, the Navy’s December 2020 instruction mandated circadian watchbills with protected sleep periods — and a 2021 Government Accountability Office report found implementation inconsistent, with 84 percent of surface warfare officers saying fatigue affects operations. A watchbill is only as good as the skipper and crew that enforce it. File that one next to your own good intentions.

What Truck Drivers Know

The civilian version of challenging sleep situations is long-haul trucking, the only other profession where people work alone all night and sleep in a berth bolted to a moving vehicle.

The U.S. National Transportation Safety Board has been studying truck-driver fatigue since 1990, when it examined 182 crashes that killed the truck driver and found fatigue the probable cause in 31 percent of them. A 1995 follow-up identified the three strongest predictors of a fatigue-related crash: the length of the driver’s last sleep, total sleep in the previous 24 hours, and whether sleep was split (the same three variables that govern a night watch). Wrist actigraphs on 73 drivers (DOT HS 811 117, US Dept of Transportation, 2009) showed 6.3 ours a day, significantly less than usual in the 24 hours before critical incidents. Bad nights cluster before bad outcomes.

The mechanism is the one we all flirt with: a long day, a short sleep, a circadian-low hour, and a brain that stopped noticing it was impaired several hours before the crash. Truckers now drive under electronic logging that cannot be fudged; cruisers get a kitchen timer and their own discipline — the harder version.

*Note: in Part 2 next month, the author will provide recommendations based on the above research. You will see suggestions for watch schedules for various crew sizes, along with many other examples of sage advice meant to improve sleep while at sea. 

 

Comments


Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *